When I saw the setter’s name I thought – it’s an IoS reprint. Well, it was on the easy side, but it’s from a Monday, and perhaps a little tougher than the Sunday puzzles tend to be. Over on the other side Pierre commented that “Raich isn’t half flexing his cryptic muscles this morning”, which about sums things up. On the gentle side, certainly, but there were one or two where the cryptic parts were a little tricky, even if the answer was often staring you in the face. My last one in would have been 25ac, but I must to admit to failing to get it. Overall as enjoyable as Raich’s puzzles always are.

COD? 4d – “Liking Dad’s treacle? (7,7)”.

To August 2013:



Saturday 25th November 2017

Lots to admire, lots to enjoy. Phi in excellent form last Saturday. Reasonably hard, but always fair and with a nice variety of clueing. Oh, and no theme.

For COD I was drawn to the cleverness of 14a ‘Inverted Commas’ but will go for the cleverly constructed 15d. Here it is again:

Had too much Ring Composer? Not I, getting Ring (second edition) (9)

And to go back to 2013  click here.

This is the second puzzle we have had in the i from this setter, the first was a fairly straightforward affair that was enjoyed by all, this time he seems to have his Inquisitor setters hat on and some of this required a bit of thinking outside the box. Thankfully he did provide a few anagrams and a couple of clues that were reasonably normal but I wouldn’t have finished without a lot of outside assistance and I must thank Beermagnet for his Fifteensquared blog where he provides all the solutions and parsing because I gave this to my wife so that she could check the answers that I couldn’t parse. Yes I found this tough. Did I enjoy it? in parts yes but some like 1dn Exposition = Act1, 17dn mosi = tick and 2dn Jelly = KY?  took the edge of it for me although I’m sure others will have found it all much more to their liking.

COD 13ac Demanding to guard border is extremely charitable  (12)

A fairly straightforward, enjoyable IoS reprint to ease us towards the end of the week. The SW corner needed a little more thought than the rest, though my LOI was 25ac elsewhere in the grid. Not because I couldn’t work out the cryptic bit, but because I was convinced it must be wrong based on the definition. The consensus over on the other side was that this was tough for a Sunday, so your mileage may vary.

COD? 16d – “Healthy drink about to be consumed by chap close to poolside area (5,3)”.

To August 2013:


i Cryptic Crossword 2125 Dac

November 29, 2017

Well, even by Dac’s high standards that was good, with a rare (first even?) mini-theme in a couple of the clues. A few entries that were new to me, but the always fair, clear cryptic parts left no doubt as to the correct answer. Another how-to guide for would-be setters. On the easy side for a Wednesday, but no less enjoyable for it.

COD? 20ac – “Woman asking for opposite of 11?”.

We’re still in the summer of 2013 over on the other side:


Which I’m presuming won’t have anything to do with computers, which is a pity because that’s a speciality of mine. As are Jigsaw puzzles, it appears. Ok, this is only half a jigsaw, but the setter has still neglected to put any numbers by the across clues. So I did so myself, because, well, it turned out to be a right pain trying to do otherwise, especially with that great big unclued entry in the middle of the grid that I kept forgetting to take into account. But anyway, the preamble. Across clues are normal, in conventional order. Hurrah. Down clues are alphabetical, 12 of them need a letter removed that we lob in the centre row in the appropriate column. Remaining down answers to be entered where they will fit. We’ve been at this kind of thing for weeks now, so it should be a doddle, shouldn’t it? At the close we’re to complete the centre row, and find a poem that describes how those down clues were entered.

Head ready to explode, onwards. So this shouldn’t be an issue. Get a load of those across answers in. Check. Get some of the downs, and see where they’ll fit. Except that they don’t. And I mean, really don’t. At least one clue that is too long for any of the barred entries, and one that is too short. Help. And that, really, was the whole of Saturday afternoon. Staring at a grid, at the answers, and trying to work out what we were supposed to do with those downs. Take out a common letter? There don’t appear to be any. Something else? I don’t have any ideas about something elses. Help, again.

To Saturday evening. A lot more staring. A couple of clues solved. The realisation that if we ignore those bars, ECO and TYPESET will fit into column 5, forming ECOTYPE and SET with the bar splitting them. And that seems to be working out with the answers I’ve got. In the centre row a sort of name forming, TEN??S??. Yes, I should have spotted who that was sooner. But by close of play Saturday I’m good for nothing.

Fast forward to Sunday evening. The fact that the down clues are in alphabetical order comes to the rescue with the big blank spaces I’ve got to the left and the right of the grid. Scrub out some answers that must be wrong. Rethink some others. What have we got?


That well known poet.

Ok, reverse that first word, Google it, and there’s the name of our poem: CROSSING THE BAR, which indeed we have been. Huzzah. Wasn’t that a struggle? No doubt you all ripped through this in a single sitting, but, well, the last thing I was expecting was that the grid would be, basically, lying. So anyway, I’m off to lick my wounds, in the hope of an easier ride next time with… Schadenfreude. Oh…

i Cryptic Crossword 2124 Punk

November 28, 2017

There may have been some glum faces in crosswordland this morning on account of all those interlinked clues, but I do hope nobody was too badly put off. Punk is just about the best in the business when it comes to this particular kind of gimmick (honourable mention for Scorpion, mind you), and this puzzle is right out of his top drawer. All the usual ingredients are there: wit, playfulness, bathos, and a smidgeon of mild ribaldry to keep the primly disapproving sorts happy.

The theme concerns various 26/4s, and the gateway clue is quite a gentle one: the real fun and games are to be found elsewhere. It’s quite a tricky crossword in my opinion, but all fair and above board. The only thematic entry which might seem a little obscure is 6d, but the clue is pitched accordingly. I’m not going to reel off a list of admirable clues today because they’re all good – but I can’t resist pointing to 24/2 which is so very Punkish. My COD is 15d:

“Extraordinary game half finished, sailor turned over first (3-7)”.

Nearly all sweetness and light in the comments on RatkojaRiku’s excellent blog at Fifteensquared when the puzzle first appeared in July 2013. The curious enumeration of 24/2 remains despite Eimi’s comment: I am still scratching my head about that so if anybody has an explanation please don’t be backward in coming forward.

A pretty straightforward puzzle from the Don to start the week. The York street was new to me, but fairly clued so no complaints. Last in was 15d which I also didn’t know, and that I needed to check to make sure it wasn’t BANTAR, or something else along those lines. Belated congratulations to Mr and Mrs Quixote.

COD? 21ac – “Very foolish ape, silly nincompoop, tried to be flirtatious (4,1,4)”. I did wonder, perhaps mischievously, if this clue was linked to 14ac at all…

To July 2013:


Saturday 18th November 2017

After a couple of stiff challenges, it’s refreshing to be reminded of last Saturday’s puzzle, which was, relatively speaking, a breeze. Maybe Phi ratcheted the difficulty level down a little for the benefit if non-French speakers. Some may have objected to all that ‘Franglais’ (the French words chosen all had a second, English meaning), but then he did write ‘Pardon my French’ across the middle of the grid – that cringe-worthy catchphrase of Pardonia.

I’ve said before that I often start by looking for anagrams – the 4 long clues were all well-advertised as such, so the grid looked half full in a jiffy, and the rest all followed as near write-ins – just the Bogeyman at 11a causing pause for thought at the end. Da Ponte at 17d was new to me, but the wordplay was super-clear.

So all said and done an enjoyable and novel challenge, for which the full blog from 2013 is here.

COD 14d Reduction in forces receiving a lot of criticism – end of warfare? (9)

I found this reprint of a Saturday prize puzzle very difficult and a couple were left unanswered. 1ac was a complete unknown, the wordplay of 7dn succeed in being so misleading that I couldn’t fathom what I was looking for and 10ac, well I can just about associate the answer with Handle but find it a bit tenuous. Both 6dn and 20ac were solved but I needed the Blog at Fifteensquared to explain. It was the NE corner that proved the most difficult to fathom even though 5ac was perhaps one of the easier to solve the starting letters it provided didn’t seem to help that much.  I can only assume its me and the excitement of Black Friday that has caused my brain to cease functioning normally 🙂

While I’m not really a fan of homonyms I think this one to be excellent so

COD  15dn  In conversation, raised problem that’s ghastly  (8)