A fairly well known poet, and if you didn’t know him, you’d probably have heard of his son. One clue that I found a little tricky to parse at 10d, but the answer was faily self-evident. One unknown at 15d, but lots of friendly checking letters. All in all a fairly straightforwad solve then, good for new and improving solvers, and for those of us feeling a little sluggish on a Monday morning.

COD? 25ac – ‘Lady excited about what has been provided by her lover proposing audaciously (8)’.

Back to October 2011:


Saturday 14th May  2016

In which Cornelian and Greywacke were familiar enough, but Upspeak and Lobar weren’t, though both (of course, this is Phi) were perfectly gettable from the wordplay and seemed like reasonable enough words in any case.

So not quite as hard as some over at the Fifteensquared blog found it (click here for their comments and full parsing) but still a good test with a sprinkling of fun here and there.

No hidden themes for once; I guess Phi just used the split lights of ‘Terracotta Army’ and ‘Beef Wellington’ at top and bottom as the seeds to get him going.

By the way, using the same anagram indicator – ‘working’ – twice in the same crossword is generally frowned upon, I can only think it was an oversight. And there seems to be an awful lot of Raita recently, as regulars will doubtless have noticed.

My COD goes to 9d, by which I see in my old copy I have written the word ‘nifty’. Here it is again:

Part of leg contained shell after explosion (8,6)

The last puzzle we had from this setter drew a few negative comments. Todays puzzle seems to me to be a more enjoyable and accessible offering with a lot of good clues. After mentioning yesterday that I don’t like the use of Trat = Restaurant the device crops up again today, ho hum. Like others I couldn’t see where the Bar in 11a came from but this is explained quite satisfactorily later in the blog, 22a with the qua=capacity didn’t seem right but having Googled it I see it is perfectly correct. Plenty of good clues to choose from today I particularly liked 13a ,20a and 25a but

COD is 2d    Reincarcerate on purpose ?  (10)


The July 2011 blog is here                        http://www.fifteensquared.net/2011/07/27/independent-7731-crosophile/

A good puzzle from Klingsor, pitched just right as far as difficulty goes at this end of the week – not too easy, but perfectly solvable, with a couple at the end (in my case 6d and 8d) that needed a little more thought. The former I guessed correctly, the latter I lobbed in and went to look at the blog to see what was going on. Still not convinced by ‘CUT’ for ‘give up’, mind.

COD? Among lots of nice clues, in particularly 19d, I’m nominating 11d – ‘How to get techie to overcome awkwardness? (5,3,3)’.

Back to September 2011:


I am in danger of being driven to distraction by Citronella’s constant harping on, and have therefore followed Onions’ advice and invested in a pair of noise-cancelling headphones. A snip at four hundred guineas. They’re frightfully good: nary a scale nor an arpeggio to be heard, leaving me free to bestow my undivided attention on the crossword.

About par for the Wednesday course today, possibly a little on the trickier side for Dac. Must say that I have my doubts about that “against” in 1ac, but otherwise all perfectly fair and above board. Highlights for me included 2, 19 and 25, but nobody will be surprised by my choice of COD, I dare say:

4ac: “Judaism’s equivalent to Irish priest wouldn’t stop talking (8)”

Solutions and discussion from November 2011 may be found at Fifteensquared.

Well, my time was completely off the scale for this puzzle, that I found extremely difficult. For a long time I didn’t have any answers, and it was only when some of the longer ones went in that the grid began to fill. Quite a few where I didn’t understand the cryptic. Typically, I’m unable to find a Fifteensquared blog, so you’ll have to make do with my efforts below. A bit of a rush job, I’ll admit. Any help with the clues I still have question marks beside would be much appreciated.

COD? 11ac – ‘Clothe yourself in gold, angel (5)’.


6 AMATI – Reverse hidden in maladroIT AMAteurs
10 GEORGIC – Sounds like JAW + GI + C
13 ROAST BEEF – (Baste for + e)*
15 sExLiFeIsNt
18 H(ALF C)ASTE – Thanks, Andy, for spotting what I’d missed!
20 ROTAVIRUS – ROTA + VIR (Latin: man or husband) + US
23 LYING – Double Def.
25 ITALICS – IT = Desirable Quality + Sounds like ALEX… (See comments, thanks again Dave!)
26/28 POINT OF DEPARTURE – (D + European port if t)*
27 T(HEM)E


1 ALOUD – DUO plus LA for lane, presumably, reversed.
2 GEHENNA – GE(HEN = Orpington Chicken)N + A (Absolute) – Many thanks to Dave in the comments…
4 IDOLS – Sounds like IDLES.
5 EG G CUP FULl – It feels like there should be a hypen there though.
14 ETHERISED – (THE)* + DESIRE reversed.
15 EXCELSIOR – Sounds like XL + SI(O)R where the O is an O Grade, a pass, in a Scottish exam. (Thanks again Dave for the help…)
19 SHIATSU – (THIS A)* + US<-
21 VOILE – Reverse hidden in DisraELI OVerview
22 SO(P) UP

A, for the most part, fairly straightforward and very enjoyable puzzle, with a number of ticks by the clues. 1ac, though, I guess would have been a guess for most solvers, and is probably stretching things a little. See also the definition at 13ac, and the use of ’round’ in 21ac.

COD? Amongst many good clues, 1d – ‘Where you might find a flat fish caught and almost abandoned (4,4).’

Here’s the IoS blog from September 2011:


Saturday 7th May 2016

Many at Fifteensquared found this a tougher than usual Phi, but I thought it was about average and, as so often happens with this setter, there’s a theme and also a Nina, both missed by me; AMIS appears hidden in the row below CARRIAGE AND PAIR, and some of his novels — TIME’S ARROW, LONDON FIELDS, SUCCESS, and MONEY make an appearance.

I’ve not too much to say about it, really (for once!) so here’s my COD:

5d  Head girl going bottomless in school dance – the stuff of life! (10)

And the 2011 blog can be found by clicking here.

Now for the nerdy bit: after Monk’s question yesterday in the Fifteensquared comments asking if it was possible to come up with a triple pangram on a standard grid with no obscurities and an average word length of over 7, I had a go myself and did so after an hour or two of pottering on Crossword Compiler with my weirdest word being SPIV.  Actually that’s a lie, it was an a.w.l. of exactly 7 – to get over that you would need at least a couple of rows where the lights couldn’t be split (7/7 or whatever) which would, I suspect, become problematic.

Like the original blogger my first pass was quite productive. I did notice the X’s, Q’s and Y’s and wondered if we had another pangram, but didn’t pursue it, well I was wrong because as you all probably spotted it was a double pangram. Irrespective of that I found the rest of the puzzle really tough with too many (for me) obscurities the worst of which I thought was 1a. Maria being a sea on the Moon. Is this really common knowledge?  A bit of a curate’s egg puzzle for me then.

My COD is 3d   Waiters will be irritated by this going forward  (5-7)

Back to Beermagnet’s excellent dissection and explanation


This was described in the comments on the original blog as being “one of the very hardest puzzles of the year”, and I have to agree. Always fair and perfectly constructed, as always with Nestor, but for the most part this took some unpicking. The SW corner and a few of the longer answers gave a bit of a foothold, so no complaints. A good example of a tough, but accessible crossword.

COD? The Star Trek reference raised a smile, but I’m nominating 13ac – ‘University that is excluded from regular feature on Telly Addicts? (5)’.

Back to September 2011:



Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 35 other followers